Mystic Soup Co | Savory Soups Sandwiches in Pawcatuck

Overview

Located at 210 S Broad St in Pawcatuck, CT, Mystic Soup Co stands out as a cherished local spot for lunch. This snug eatery specializes in hearty sandwiches and artisan soups that change daily, making every visit a new experience. The menu highlights, including their Rueben and Pastrami sandwiches, showcase fresh, quality bread and well-seasoned fillings that satisfy both quick bites and more leisurely meals.

The chicken ala king soup and other rotating varieties attract loyal customers who appreciate the depth of flavor packed into each bowl. Reviewers often praise the soups for their rich texture and bold taste, with selections like tomato basil, chili, and inventive blends such as chicken-red pepper-white bean-squash making for comforting, memorable eats. Pairing soup with a sandwich—especially a grilled cheese—turns a simple lunch into a fulfilling occasion, particularly on a rainy day.

The space itself is compact, making it better suited for takeout rather than dine-in, which is ideal for the busy lunch crowd or those looking to enjoy their meal by the nearby Mystic waterfront. This setup positions Mystic Soup Co as a go-to for both local workers and visitors seeking a quick yet satisfying meal with a handcrafted touch.

What truly elevates this spot is the genuine warmth from the staff, enhancing the welcoming atmosphere despite the small footprint. Whether you’re after a robust soup, a perfectly assembled sandwich, or simply a fast and flavorful lunch in Pawcatuck, Mystic Soup Co offers quality and care in every serving, earning its place as a beloved gem in the local culinary scene.

Menu Highlights

See Full Menu

Amenities & Services

Popular for

Lunch

Solo dining

Offerings

Comfort food

Healthy options

Quick bite

Vegan options

Vegetarian options

Atmosphere

Casual

What Customers Say

Erik Lili (Eri)

Dec 11,2025

5/5

Great soup and sandwich local gem. My favorite is the terry. You get the option of coleslaw or potato salad. Random if you don’t ask. Soups are really good which changes everyday. He posts 2 soup of the day sometimes on facebook. Soups from yesterday are in the fridge in there’s leftovers

Brian McInerney

Dec 11,2025

5/5

This is a great value. Tomato Basil was absolutely delicious. Add a grilled cheese and it was a perfect meal for a rainy day. Guy working behind the counter super friendly. Definitely hit this spot but don't miss it, the sign is quite small.

Kristin Brown

Dec 11,2025

5/5

This is a perfect location for take-out during lunchtime. I find it hard to enjoy a meal inside since it's a small space, but you can always drive down to Mystic and eat near the water. The sandwiches are delicious, and the bread is fresh. Personally, I think they have the best chicken salad. I highly recommend checking them out!

Amy Christian

Dec 11,2025

5/5

I’ve been here 2-3 times, and their soup is outstanding! So much flavor packed into every spoonful! Today I had the chicken-red pepper-white bean-squash soup, and it was fabulous. I’m surprised I remembered to snap a pic before it was gone!

Denise P Clement

Dec 11,2025

5/5

What they do to soup is unhinged …. I actually had Chili on this day in question and Oh my the taste and alone is magnificent but now add a beautiful pc of bread delish !! Hands down a 5 all the way around !!!

Sue Clark Mirra

Dec 11,2025

5/5

Best turkey Reuben I’ve ever had. And I’ve had many! Minestrone and chicken rice and apricot soup was delicious!!! Off the beaten path for sure.

Rob Everich

Dec 11,2025

5/5

Hands down delicious. Chicken salad on a toasted ciabatta roll. Coming back for the variety of hearty red meat sandwiches. Soup was sold out- cause it’s that good. Yum.

Ethan Gross

Dec 11,2025

5/5

recently visited Mystic Soup Company with my wife and three children, and we had an outstanding experience. We shared two sandwiches—a Reuben and a Cuban—both of which were absolutely delicious, showcasing the care and quality put into every dish. The flavors were bold, fresh, and perfectly balanced. The service was exceptional, with staff exuding genuine warmth and friendliness. It was clear this is a beloved local spot; the owner knew many customers by name, creating a welcoming, community-driven atmosphere. His pride in his work shone through, elevating the entire dining experience. The pricing was spot-on, offering great value for such high-quality food. Mystic Soup Company is a gem that combines fantastic sandwiches with heartfelt service, making it a must-visit lunch spot. We can’t wait to return! Ethan and family of 5 from Maine